Wednesday, February 16, 2011

Follow up: Anne Fausto-Sterling Sexing the Body: “Gender and Genitals” and “Should There Only Be Two Sexes?”

“Gender and Genitals”
Fausto-Sterling writes about the surgeries that doctors will perform on babies when their sex is not perfectly clear. She clearly disagrees with this practice for multiple reasons. She talks about how doctors will not tell the parents all the details about the surgery done to their child. I think this is wrong. A parent should be able to receive all the information about what is happening to their child. By not telling the parents, it is allowing the doctor to make choices about a child that is not theirs. Fausto-Sterling goes on to talk about the debate with nature vs. nurture and why the doctor does not tell the parents about their child’s surgery in more detail. I do think that nurture is usually more important than nature. Your parents could be murders, but that should not reflect on you. Still that is not an excuse for not telling the parents.
I was shocked when I read about how doctors choose what sex to make the intersex babies. The pole vs. hole line was awful. I agree with Tira that it is encouraging a patriarchal society. I think that a penis size should not be the deciding matter of what sex to make the baby, but I am not a guy.
This chapter really made me wonder what I would do if I suddenly found out that I was an intersex baby. It is a crazy idea to think and I am curious if parents usually tell their children or not.

“Should There Only Be Two Sexes?”
In this chapter Fausto-Sterling talks a lot about how she thinks things should change. (I have to admit I was happy to see she had suggestions…) I am curious about the part where she mentions how medical students traumatize children by sitting in on their medical examinations. I thought that patients had the right to tell the doctor that they only want the doctor to be in the room? Also, a medical examination might be uncomfortable for any sex, let alone someone who is intersex or someone who had surgery to change their intersex state. It is not that I am disagreeing with Fausto-Sterling’s points, but I do think that it is interesting.
One point in the chapter really caught my eye. It was when Fausto-Sterling talks about how Americans argue against genital mutilation in different cultures, but it occurs within our own. This reminded me of the book Cosmopolitanism by Kwame Anthony Appiah, which every freshman (2014) had to read before coming to Colgate. In Cosmopolitanism Appiah writes about genital mutilation and how Americans should not be so judgmental, that we did not understand the culture so we could not understand the practice. If we look at the intersex surgeries from a cultural view then we learn a lot about our society. Perhaps the reason we want sex to be either male or female is because men and women are treated differently. So when we participate in a patriarchal society what happens to the person who is neither a man to be placed higher nor a woman to be placed lower?

6 comments:

  1. Molly,

    I think you bring up a great point about the nature vs. nurture debate. While I do agree with you that nurture does trump nature, there are cases where nature becomes more important than nurture (for example the incident Fausto-Sterling explains about Jane/John). We have to question to what extend does nature and nurture plays in the development of a child. I do think that nature and nurture both contributes to a child's growth and gender behavior, but to what extend is not clear.

    I like how you made a text to text connection with Fausto-Sterling and Appiah. He is completely correct that America should not be judgmental about genital mutation. As we have discussed in class how Americans do condone alteration of body parts from plastic surgeries to changing the sex of intersex babies, America cannot be judgmental of other culture's practices. However, as an ethnocentric society the United States is, it does denounces countries that do practice genital mutation.

    Lastly, I like your reasoning to why society does not accept a wider spectrum of gender. Your idea that our binary gender system scribe gender treatment and produces a power dynamic between men and women is legitimate. Not only is our society not fond of ambiguity, it is also not fond of deviating power. I predict if we were to admit intersex into your gender scale then, they will be the sex that is the most inferior. Society's negative point of view on intersex will only fester a greater discrimination against them. However, this is not a discouragement to not expand out gender scale. America just likes to put different groups of people as the target and minority of society. I hope that once intersex is apparent in more conversation people will be more knowledge and acceptance of another sex.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Naked Tamil aunty ass hole fucked by young guy in doggy style on bed in hotel room




      Indian black cock with tight pussy nude girls xxx hardcore live latest xxx




      Unmarried young girl tight pussy injected first time,School Girl Tight Pussy Hardcore sex xxx




      Desi girlfriend smoking hot showing her boobs cunt and ass teaser pics,indian Desi Couple fucking in Forest




      sexy hot nude girl porn sex video desi boobs doodhwali indian girl




      Indian desi sister pure latest sexy nude video download,Vidya Balan Unseen Hot Photos in Saree




      My Round Big Ass Mother Forced Fucked By My Five College Friend




      Sexy Hot Nepali Hindu Baby Cropped Public Sex,Pakistani Girls Shaved Pussy Show And Big Ass Pictures




      Indian deshi girlfriend showing her hairy beautiful pussy,Most beautiful muslim girls in the world




      Tamil Mallu Housewife Bhabhi Big Dirty Ass Ready For Best Fuck




      Beautiful unsatisfied sexy north Indian housewife nisha fucked with her new young boyfriend




      Katrina Kaif Semi Naked in Stylish Post Showing Her Big Soft Boobs and Cute Nipples




      Indian Gay Boys hot kisses showing their Cocks,Real fucked hard pics of nude desi wife by her husband




      South Indian Busty Porn-star Manali Ghosh Double Penetration Sex For Money




      South indian hot bhabhi enjoying her first night with her husband in bedroom




      sex video of tight pussy of desi college girl banged by boyfriend




      Desi Arab wife in burkha sucking penis of her husband,Desi Couple Homemade Awesame Sex Scandal




      Hot arabian college teen Jasmin exposing her sexy booty and fucking with dildo on cam




      Desi indian naughty wife oilly pussy and hot young ass fuck,Indian Mom Sucks Her Son's Big Cock




      Priya Rai fucked and facialized by a huge hard cock,Katrina Kaif Posing Nude for Holly Photoshoot




      Hot Bangla beauty showing off herself nude for her lover exclusive MMS capture




      Big boobed Village sister fucked her brother,Indian Muslim Girl Playing With Boobs and Showing Her Tight Pussy

      Delete
    2. Katrina Kaif Totally Naked Among Crowd Enjoying Playing Guitar Showing Her Sexy Cute Flashy Nude Body




      Hollywood sexy hot nude fuck sex porn xxx indian girls nude chat dating




      Desi indian naughty wife oilly pussy and hot young ass





      Hot sexy parineeti chopra bra breast and figure size with stunning exclusive latest photos




      Hard sex Big Anal Asses with Jayden James10 min,Sunny Leone Very Hot Sexy Photos Stills





      Indian nude housewife exposed her big ass nude image,Sunny Leone Sexy Images download




      Teen Indian house wife in a yellow saree exposing her hot boobs and tight navel




      Indian first night sex photo nude indian house wifes download




      Hot desi indian busty wife ass fucked in dogy style,Actress Meghna Naidu Hot Sexy Latest Photo




      Kareena Kapoor Nude Enjoying Double Penetration in Pussy,Deshi girl sexy photos Download




      Real Life Homemade Aunty Removed Saree Expose Big Ass Images




      Really cute Japanese Schoolgirl shows her hot pink virgin pussy and stinky anus




      Nude american girl showing her ass in doggy style,Drunks Desi Girl Raped By Biggerman




      Indian prostitute showing her boobs and pussy on bed,Tollywood sexy model sexy gallery




      Mallika Sherawat Showing Her Boobs And Pussy,Anushka Lifting Her Legs Spreading Her Pussy




      Just Amazing Collection of Young Wife with her husband at 1st Honeymoon Night




      Mallu Aunty Fucking Photo,Desi Couple Fucking,Sexy South Indian university girl nude big boobs and wet pussy




      Hot Desi Babe Goes Nude Showing Lovely Ass Tits And Cunt Pics,Ramya Krishna Big Boobs Pressed Nicely




      Sonam Kapoor Hot Navel Show in Aisha HQ scan,Very Hot Indian Bhabi Showing Boobs




      Teen Girl Trying Dog Sex First Time,Desi Village Bhabhi Pure pussy Photos




      3gp XXX Hot Sexy Porn Video Indian Girl Pakistan Boy,Sunny's Exclusive Hot Sari Pics




      Mallu wife getting kissed pussy licked and fucked hard by husband pics




      Aishwarya Rai Fucking with Two Huge Cocks,Anushka Shetty Lifting Her Skirt To Show Pussy




      Katrina Kaif Braless Showing Her Huge Juicy Soft Boobs and Cute Pink Nipples Looking Gorgeous and Sexy

      Delete
    3. Katrina Kaif Getting Fucked with Big Penis




      Ayesha Takia Nude Showing Sexy Body And Big Tits, Nipples




      Sexy busty newly wed wife making pussy fingering video for her husband




      Full nude desi bhabi with servant in bedroom enjoying free hardcore sex




      Priyamani Nude Exposing Her Bouncing Boobs,Nipples And Navel Without Saree




      Rambha Exposing Her Hairy Pussy And Fucking Ass Fully Naked Sex At Hotel




      Anushka Sharma Pulled Bra Panty Shows Pink Pussy And Boobs




      Indian Aunty Sucking Hairy Lund And Group Fucking Porn Movie




      Nazriya Nazim Nude Bending and Showing her Hanging Boobs and Nipples




      Nude Indian Desi School Girls Classroom Sex Movie And Porn Pictures




      Semi Naked in Stylish Post Showing Her Big Soft Boobs and Cute Nipples




      Big ass housewife enjoy fuck without petticoat doggystyle




      Desi Hot Indian Model Naked Photoshoot In Public Place




      Shaved Korean Amateur Getting Fingered To Warm Up Before The Real Fun




      Telugu Hasband Forces His Wife To Do Prostitute With Clear Audio




      Bollywood actress sayali bhagat topless strip her panty nude




      Mother-Son Sex Scandals, Deep Anal Fuck Video




      Hot aunty sleeping up saree,Nude showing her beautiful ass



      Nazriya Nazim Nude Bending and Showing her Hanging Boobs and Nipples




      South Indian Mature Aunty Fucking 20 Years Old Young Boy




      Telugu Sexy Neighbor Bhabhi Strips Blouse Showing Nude Body Images




      Horny big boobs babe fucked hard and getting cum MMS




      Riya Sen Removed Underwear And Fully Nude Shows Her Pussy




      Hot Desi Couple 40 Min Good Quality Sex With Many Position




      Actress Jyothika Nude On Bed And Fucking Hardcore With Her New Fan




      Awesome Big boob Indian girl sucking and fucking must watch video

      Delete